The Powder Toy

Simon

@boxmein (View Post)
Disregard what savask says about your Header image, It looks awesome, but I think you should replace the Mario thing with something else; I don't want people to get the impression they're playing a Mario game, nor do I want any hassle with trademarks

m3mggl

my next work :D http://www.mediafire.com/view/?ddn3brhhzb95z2e#

savask

@Simon (View Post)

Ehm, you're not the only judge here, Mr. Admin :-) Maybe other judges are on my side.

@m3mgg

Hmm, show more features and make more use of the space. You can make the planet bigger, letters better, add UFOs and so on.

DJspiderize

@savask (View Post)

Well, I quite like boxmein's one. No offence or anything but you are being kinda harsh on the submissions so far. Give positive as well as negative and you'll probably get more entries. At the moment it seems to me that you're giving out the wrong message about this competition. I understand that you want this to be the best it can. But you know, be nice to the people that have actually took the time to enter.

I'm sorry if I sound rude, that's just my opinion.

savask

@DJspiderize (View Post)

"Am I?" (C)

I don't think that I'm being harsh. For example, I liked boxmein's boxshot submission, but to my mind his header image looks too trippy :-P

And as about others, I just try to filter out submissions which don't show gameplay features.

Also, nearly all my words are suggestions. I'm being so nice and kind, that I show people a way to make a cool picture :3

DJspiderize

Suggestions? Suggestions are "maybe you could do this" or "this might make it better." Not "Do this" or "Do that"

Maybe boxmein's one was a bad example. But I'm just saying as well as giving people your "suggestions" you maybe tell them something positive about their work as well.