Comments on Creations are in Reverse Order

  • DRAGONF0RCE
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    The comment list on creations are in order of newest on top and oldest on the bottom. This is in reverse; since you read from top to bottom, the first comment should be on top and the last (newest) one should be on the bottom.
  • Jammy45
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    Um no. just open in browser to see the first comment and so on.
  • theguitarguy
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    So you want to have the first comment forever locked on the comment displayer?
  • DRAGONF0RCE
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    No, it should scroll from the top as well. For example, you might see:

    ...
    Comment 6
    Comment 7
    Comment 8
    Comment 9
    Comment 10

    Instead of:

    Comment 10
    Comment 9
    Comment 8
    Comment 7
    Comment 6
    ...
  • theguitarguy
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    Ah, i get what you're saying now
  • Neospector
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    @DRAGONF0RCE (View Post)
    You do realize how time-consuming to view and against-logic that is, right?
  • keperitan
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    maybe he meant it should be scrollable?
  • DRAGONF0RCE
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink

    Neospector:

    @DRAGONF0RCE!164309
    You do realize how time-consuming to view and against-logic that is, right?
    What are you talking about? All I'm asking is that the comments should be listed top-to-bottom, since that's how most people read, instead of bottom-to-top.
  • Neospector
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    @DRAGONF0RCE (View Post)
    Yes, but normally people read comments from latest to oldest, in order for them to address important issues right away.
    Making it oldest to newest is fine for a forum, where most people read the OP before saying something, but in comments it doesn't work; you don't have to view the first comment to talk about the save properly.
  • DRAGONF0RCE
    18th Sep 2011 Member 0 Permalink
    Please explain it more clearly, I'm not really sure how reading the oldest comment first would be easier to understand.